The AFC East enters 2026 looking dramatically different after New England ended Buffalo’s five-year reign atop the division. The Patriots authored one of the NFL’s biggest turnarounds, going 14-3 under first-year coach Mike Vrabel and riding that resurgence all the way to the Super Bowl before falling to Seattle.
But New England’s revival was only part of the offseason upheaval. Buffalo made the stunning decision to fire Sean McDermott, despite his 98-50 record, five AFC East championships and eight playoff appearances in nine seasons.
Miami also hit the reset button, moving on from Mike McDaniel after a 35-33 four-year run that produced no postseason victories. The New York Jets, meanwhile, finished 3-14 but elected to give Aaron Glenn a second season to continue rebuilding a roster that underwent significant changes.
The AFC East Story in 2026
That leaves the AFC East with three teams navigating major transitions and New England trying to prove last season was the beginning of something sustainable rather than a one-year surge.
The Patriots may enter as the team to beat, but Buffalo remains dangerous, Miami is starting over, and New York has nowhere to go but up. With that much uncertainty, the division presents some intriguing opportunities in the win-total market.
Here’s how all four teams stack up, and which ones are positioned to go Over or Under their number (totals via DraftKings):
Buffalo Bills Over 10.5 Wins
There are legitimate questions surrounding Buffalo.
Sean McDermott is gone, Joe Brady takes over as head coach, and defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard is installing a three-man front after years of four-man looks. The transition could create early growing pains.
Still, 10.5 wins feels low for a franchise led by Josh Allen.
Buffalo went 12-5 last season, with an offense that ranked fourth in scoring at 28.3 points per game and fourth in total offense. The Bills also led the NFL with 2,714 rushing yards and 30 rushing touchdowns, proving they were far more than an Allen-dependent passing attack.
That foundation should help the team navigate defensive adjustments. DJ Moore gives Allen the established boundary weapon Buffalo has lacked, while Dalton Kincaid offers significant upside if healthy. In only 12 games last season, Kincaid recorded 571 yards and five touchdowns on 39 catches.
DJ Moore SHINES in His Bills Debut With Josh Allen 🔥
3 REC, 61 YDS, including a 32-yard grab. pic.twitter.com/W0IUK9Y54a
— Football Performances (@NFLPerformances) August 15, 2026
The defense does not need to become dominant. Buffalo allowed 21.5 points per game, ranking 12th, while finishing first in passing yards allowed. The primary weakness was run defense, which Leonhard’s rebuilt front is designed to address. The secondary also gains depth from a healthy Max Hairston and second-round pick Davison Igbinosun.
Most importantly, Buffalo has reached double-digit wins in six consecutive seasons and at least 11 victories in each of them. The schedule is challenging, but the opponent slate is roughly league average, and the Bills close with Miami and the Jets.
Coaching and scheme changes create uncertainty. Allen provides certainty. Buffalo won 12 games with defensive weaknesses last season and has now added Moore to an already elite offense.
The Bills only need 11 wins, a standard they have made routine.
Miami Dolphins Under 4.5 Wins
The Dolphins aren’t simply changing coaches; they’re changing almost everything. Mike McDaniel’s offense is gone, Jeff Hafley wants a tougher identity, and Malik Willis replaces Tua Tagovailoa. Miami also lost Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, leaving De’Von Achane as the offense’s lone established centerpiece.
That makes Under 4.5 wins worth considering.
Hafley is trying to build a physical, run-oriented team, but changing an organization’s identity takes time. He went 22-26 at Boston College, and now must install a new culture while managing one of the NFL’s youngest rosters.
Willis showed promise in Green Bay, completing 78.7% of his passes with 6 touchdowns, no interceptions and 10.9 yards per attempt in 11 appearances. However, he made only three starts, and succeeding in limited packages is different from leading an offense for 17 games.
Who’s ready to (hopefully) see Malik Willis COOK today? 😤
(🎥: @GhostOfAdamGase) pic.twitter.com/fhzruVvxdA
— SleeperDolphins (@SleeperMiami) August 22, 2026
Miami’s receiving corps is also significantly weaker. Without Hill and Waddle, defenses can focus more attention on Achane. Offensive line concerns remain, highlighted by reports of New York recording at least six sacks during a recent joint practice.
The schedule adds to the challenge. Miami faces nine games against seven 2025 playoff teams, with five on the road, including trips to Denver, Green Bay, Minnesota and San Francisco. That’s a difficult assignment for a young team learning new systems.
The Dolphins went 7-10 last season but changed their coach, general manager, quarterback and much of the roster. Reaching five wins would require this younger, less experienced team to nearly match last year’s total.
This looks more like a developmental season than a win-now campaign. A first-year coach, first-year starting quarterback, young roster, weakened receiving corps and difficult schedule create too many paths to losing.
New England Patriots Over 10.5 Wins
The schedule is tougher, but New England’s win total is still too low at 10.5 after a 14-3 season and Super Bowl appearance. The Patriots didn’t merely benefit from an easy schedule last year — they dominated it, ranking second in scoring at 28.8 points per game, fourth in total offense and fourth in scoring defense at 18.8 points allowed.
Everything starts with Drake Maye, who threw for more than 4,000 yards during an MVP-caliber regular season. His two-interception Super Bowl performance showed areas for improvement, but Maye finished second in MVP voting and enters his third year with more experience. New England has also upgraded around him, adding A.J. Brown and Romeo Doubs while giving offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels another explosive weapon in TreVeyon Henderson.
A.J. had himself a day 💯 pic.twitter.com/Gcys9mI3c8
— New England Patriots (@Patriots) August 20, 2026
The defense should remain strong, with Kevin Byard III adding veteran leadership to a secondary featuring Christian Gonzalez and Carlton Davis III. Christian Barmore and Milton Williams anchor a front that helped New England allow fewer than 19 points per game last season.
Schedule regression is real. The Patriots face first-place opponents Pittsburgh, Jacksonville and Seattle, along with difficult road games against Seattle, Detroit, the Chargers and Kansas City. Repeating 14 wins is unlikely, but the question is whether they can win 11.
There are enough manageable games to make that realistic, including two matchups with the Jets, two against Miami and home games against Las Vegas and Minnesota. Even if Buffalo wins the division and New England struggles against the league’s best teams, the Patriots’ quarterback, offensive firepower and defensive foundation give them a strong chance to reach 11 victories.
Regression is not collapse. New England has too much established infrastructure to fall from 14 wins to a borderline .500 team.
New York Jets Over 5.5 Wins
The Jets don’t need to make the playoffs to cash this ticket. After going 3-14 last season, they only need three more wins, and a second year under Aaron Glenn should bring meaningful improvement.
New York upgraded its defense with first-round edge rusher David Bailey, linebacker Demario Davis and defensive tackles T’Vondre Sweat and David Onyemata. Bailey adds needed pass-rush ability, Davis brings leadership and Sweat should help against the run.
The Jets finished with just 23 sacks and 11 takeaways last season. Even modest improvement in those areas could turn several close losses into wins.
not a bad start 😮💨
📺: #NYJvsPIT on @NFLonCBS, @paramountplus pic.twitter.com/Ias9l0WIsu
— New York Jets (@nyjets) August 21, 2026
Offensively, Frank Reich replaces a first-time play caller, giving Geno Smith an experienced coordinator. Smith doesn’t need to be elite; he needs to resemble the quarterback who went 27-22 as Seattle’s starter from 2022-24, completing nearly 69% of his passes and throwing for more than 12,000 yards.
He also has a strong supporting cast. Garrett Wilson remains a legitimate No. 1 receiver, Omar Cooper Jr. adds another weapon, and Breece Hall provides explosive ability as both a runner and receiver. A solid offensive line should allow Reich to build around Hall and create favorable play-action opportunities.
Three-win teams rarely stay that bad after upgrading their quarterback, coaching and roster. The AFC East also offers opportunities, particularly against a rebuilding Miami team led by Malik Willis.
This is ultimately a bet on competence replacing dysfunction. The Jets don’t need to contend for the division. They simply need to improve from 3-14 to 6-11, which is a reasonable expectation.
W.G. Ramirez is a veteran sports writer from Las Vegas and a Staff Writer at TeamFB7.com. Follow him on X at @WillieGRamirez.
Editor's Pick
2026 NFL Preseason: 5 Things to Watch in Week 2