Ohio State WR Jeremiah Smith is the betting favorite to win the Heisman Trophy, but Miami QB Darian Mensah has a path to win college football’s top prize as the race continues.
It’s clear there has been overwhelming sentiment and movement to reward Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith for being the top wide receiver in college football over the last three years.

His Heisman Trophy campaign began before the season and gained a groundswell of support and momentum when he got off to a smoldering start through the first six games (48 catches for 916 yards and 11 TDs), including back-to-back 200-yard outputs.
But then Buckeyes quarterback Julian Sayin sustained a shoulder injury that will keep him out at least through the rest of the regular season. With true freshman Luke Fahey taking over at QB, Smith put up his two lowest yardage totals of the season (68 yards vs. Indiana with Sayin going down late in that game and 83 yards vs. USC in a deflating loss).
Even still, Smith scored touchdowns in both of those contests, put up 133 yards and a score in a subsequent loss to Oregon and then led the Buckeyes to a much-needed win over Northwestern with 11 catches for 117 yards and a TD.
Recent Rankings: Nov. 12 | Nov. 5 | Oct. 29
Nothing has changed in terms of Smith’s stature in the sport — he’s a generational talent, the best of the best at his position and will be one of the very top picks in the 2027 NFL Draft — but the reality is he’s no longer putting up numbers at a historically relevant pace.
And that was what really justified his status as the Heisman favorite, beyond it being a career achievement honor (which some voters will surely still factor into their decision).
(With Miami star wideout Malachi Toney now out for the rest of the regular season, Smith should be a lock to at least win the prestigious Biletnikoff Award as the top pass-catcher in college football.)
Does Jeremiah Smith Still Deserve To Be The Heisman Trophy Favorite?
Only three players have ever won the Heisman as primarily wide receivers — Notre Dame’s Tim Brown in 1987, Michigan’s Desmond Howard in 1991 and Alabama’s DeVonta Smith in 2020. Colorado’s Travis Hunter won it in 2024 because of his rare two-way prowess as both as wide receiver and cornerback, and other winners in the past (especially in the older era) have been partly WRs among other positions.
Brown and Howard were also elite return specialists who scored multiple touchdowns on kickoffs/punts in their Heisman seasons, and Smith doesn’t do any of that. So with the standard being what it is for WRs to win college football’s top honor, it stands to reason he’d need a historically relevant season statistically.
Using DeVonta Smith As A Heisman Trophy Test Case
Basically, the comparison is DeVonta Smith, who had 117 catches for 1,856 yards and 23 receiving TDs (plus a rushing TD and punt return TD) in 13 games.
Those stats were so far and above the rest of college football that Smith finished with 31 more receptions than any other FBS receiver, 663 more receiving yards and 4 more receiving TDs. He also did that for a dominant, undefeated national championship team.
Jeremiah Smith’s Buckeyes are unlikely to even make the 12-team College Football Playoff with three losses already.
As for his stats, with 80 receptions for 1,317 yards and 15 TDs in 10 games, Smith is on pace for 96 catches for 1,580 yards and 18 TDs in 12 games, assuming he doesn’t play in a postseason game of any kind.
That would put him in range of the Big Ten single-season records of 1,606 receiving yards (by Ohio State’s Jaxon Smith-Njigba in 13 games in 2021) and 19 receiving TDs (Howard in his Heisman season).
Those are awesome numbers — are they enough to make him the clear choice race for the Heisman Trophy? Maybe that depends on what happens these next two weeks against Nebraska and Michigan.
Smith is tied for second nationally in catches (behind FAU’s Easton Messer‘s 86) but tops in the Power 4, second nationally in receiving yards (behind Oregon State’s Jesse Legree‘s 1,349) but tops in the Power 4 by a margin of 272 and he’s tied for first with Legree in receiving TDs (most in the P4).
Smith is having a phenomenal season to cap a legendary career — but is he the most deserving Heisman Trophy candidate?
Per DraftKings Sportsbook, Smith indeed remains the overwhelming Heisman favorite at -144 odds, followed by Miami QB Darian Mensah (+340), Utah QB Devon Dampier (+700) and Notre Dame QB CJ Carr (+940).
There is a strong argument to make that Mensah can still shake up those odds quite a bit between now the final voting. Allow us to make the case …

How Darian Mensah Can Win The Heisman Trophy
Mensah, the Duke transfer in his first season at Miami, is putting up numbers that in most years would make him the far-and-away favorite for the Heisman.
He is completing 76.3% of his passes (the best mark in the entire FBS) for 3,076 yards (fifth-most nationally, third in FBS), 29 TDs (tied for second) and 2 INTs.
He is the only quarterback in the top 20 nationally in passing yards with less than 3 interceptions and the only P4 QB in the top 10 with less than 6.
Mensah is the engineer of the highest-scoring offense in college football (44.1 PPG) for a 9-1 Miami team slotted 7th in the CFP rankings.
The Impact Of Losing Toney
For most of the season, Mensah’s Heisman case was undercut slightly by the presence of his teammate Toney as the Hurricanes stars were splitting the vote, so to speak. With Toney out for the remainder of the regular season with a high-ankle sprain, missing the team’s 31-24 loss to Notre Dame, the CFP committee quickly vaulted Miami down the rankings below a pair of two-loss SEC teams (as if to suggest Mensah couldn’t recover without his star wideout).
In the loss to Notre Dame, Mensah wasn’t quite as sharp as he’s been, completing 24 of 43 passes for 269 yards, 3 TDs and just his second pick of the season, while playing behind most of the game.
But what he did last week in a 36-25 win over a good Duke team bears just as much weight and attention.
Mensah completed 30 of 41 passes or 382 yards and a TD, spreading the ball around with five players logging at least 39 receiving yards.
Miami closes with favorable matchups against Virginia Tech and Boston College, both at home. The Hurricanes should then be in the ACC championship game, giving Mensah three opportunities to pad his numbers and further his Heisman case before the votes are due.
If Smith is just pedestrian in Ohio State’s remaining two games (including a touch matchup vs. Michigan) or the Buckeyes lose another one, and Mensah plays like he did against Duke (and most everyone else) the rest of the way, those Heisman odds are going to look much, much tighter before the ballots are cast.
With that in mind, we’d argue Mensah is the smart value bet at this point.
Smith may remain the sentimental choice for many — and Ohio State will surely be feeding him even more than normal to help his campaign — but Mensah is every bit as deserving and has the better remaining runway to swing the race.
