The Daniel Jones Debacle Punctuates A Year Of Abject Mismanagement For Colts

The Indianapolis Colts released quarterback Daniel Jones on Friday, admitting a colossal mistake and continuing to look like one of the worst-run teams in the NFL.

We can continue to recognize and appreciate the Arizona Cardinals’ Monti Ossenfort for being the worst general manager in football, but that’s only because the Indianapolis Colts don’t presently have a GM anymore.

(Did Ossenfort deserve to be shoehorned into this column just to catch a stray jab? Yes, the answer is always yes.)

But in terms of NFL team dysfunction overall, none bungled the last year worse than the Indianapolis Colts, continuing Friday with the release of quarterback Daniel Jones a mere 10 days after the trade deadline — when national NFL reporters put it out there that Indy was not interested in trading the highly paid, poorly performing QB.

Daniel Jones #17 of the Indianapolis Colts reacts against the Dallas Cowboys after the game at Lucas Oil Stadium on November 08, 2026 in Indianapolis, Indiana.
(Photo by Michael Hickey/Getty Images)

Why? Well, that’s but one of many head-scratching decisions by the Colts that lack clarity or discernible logic.

Maybe the answers are in the notebook Colts owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon cryptically writes in from the sidelines during games.

But so far, the only thing her uniquely hands-on approach to team ownership has produced are fingerprints all over a football mismanagement crime scene.

Some of it is certainly bad luck, but no team in the league has had a worse 12.5 months, and there’s more than enough blame has to spread around.

After all, Irsay-Gordon publicly put since-fired general manager Chris Ballard and surely-soon-to-be-fired head coach Shane Steichen on notice after last season that there would be consequences if the Colts didn’t perform better in 2026. So it seems only fair for the most personally involved NFL owner to share in the culpability of the team’s continued collapse.

Let’s review.

A Year Of Utter And Complete Mismanagement For The Colts

Over the last year …

– The Colts traded two first-round draft picks to the New York Jets for cornerback Sauce Gardner to bolster their defense after an encouraging 7-2 start. The team has gone 4-15 since then while initiating a full-scale tear down. Rough.

– When Jones tore his Achilles last December, derailing that promising season, the Colts signed a 44-year-old high school football coach who hadn’t thrown a pass in the NFL in five years to take over at the position. No, this wasn’t a Disney movie — that really happened. And while the brief and bizarre return of Philip Rivers was a fun story for nostalgic football fans, the Colts nonetheless averaged 20 points and Rivers a mere 181.3 passing yards in his three starts as the team lost the remainder of its games.

– Despite Jones coming off one of the most substantial injuries in the sport, the Colts nonetheless negotiated against themselves to award a two-year, $88-million contract (of which only the first year was fully guaranteed) to a quarterback who had played half a season of solid football — his first stretch of sustained positive performance in three years. That seemed exorbitant, especially considering Jones derived a significant percentage of his value from his mobility and impact running the ball but was returning to action just nine months after a devastating Achilles tear. Not surprisingly, he was a non-factor in the ground game this year while regressing overall (1,974 passing yards, 7 TDs and 13 INTs) to the previous level of substandard play that got him released by the New York Giants.

– Meanwhile, Indianapolis had already put itself in a salary cap crunch by panic-paying free agent wide receiver Alec Pierce a four-year, $114-million contract (with $84 million in guaranteed money) despite the fact that Pierce had never even caught 50 passes in a season.

To accommodate that albatross of a contract, the Colts had to give former WR1 Michael Pittman Jr. away for free (a late-round pick swap) to the Pittsburgh Steelers among other cuts (like trading away leading tackler Zaire Franklin to the Green Bay Packers, letting edge rusher Kwity Paye leave in free agency, etc.).

This is not a 20/20 hindsight criticism — we wrote about the absurdity of the Pierce contract in the moment. And that was without even knowing that he’d wait until signing that deal before having surgery on his ankle/heel in March, causing him to miss the entire offseason and most of the preseason before re-injuring himself two games into this season. He hasn’t played since, and it’s more than mildly concerning that a player whose major appeal was elite speed as a downfield threat has a problematic ankle/heel. Just a disastrous investment overall.

– Going all-in on Pierce left the Colts with a razor-thin WR corps for a QB with now-compromised mobility who had already proven to be a limited passer throughout his career. Is it really a surprise Indy ranks 30th in the league in total offense (276.6 YPG) and 26th in scoring (19.2 PPG)? Really?

– Meanwhile, without a first-round pick due to the regrettable Gardner trade and the salary cap crunch from overpaying Jones and Pierce, the Colts were limited in how they could plug major holes on their roster — especially on defense. Consequently, it’s also not a total surprise the team ranks 26th in the league defensively (354.8 YPG).

– All of that said, firing Ballard was the most sensible move Irsay-Gordon has made, but doing it in October and turning the roster over to an interim general manager (Ballard’s longtime assistant GM Ed Dodds) just weeks before the trade deadline didn’t necessarily make things any better.

– The Colts traded away standout offensive guard Quenton Nelson, veteran defensive tackle DeForest Buckner and wide receivers Josh Downs and Keenan Allen to collect draft assets — like a team heading toward a rebuild would do. If doing that made sense, simultaneously declining to trade their best and most valuable asset — star running back Jonathan Taylor — made no sense.

Isn’t there an overwhelming enough abundance of empirical evidence that it serves no purpose to have a highly paid running back on a rebuilding team with a bad offense around him?

Well, Taylor turns 28 years old in a couple months, has a lot of miles on his legs and a concerning career-low 4.0 yards per carry this season while being the third-highest-paid RB in the league at $22 million a year with two years left on his contract. Indianapolis isn’t going to be good next year (or perhaps the year after that either), it doesn’t have a first-round pick in the upcoming draft and yet it was determined to hold onto an aging, high-priced RB for the duration of this rebuild? Inexplicable.

– But not as inexplicable as holding onto Jones. The Ringer’s Tom Pelissero reported that QB-needy teams showed interest in Jones, and ESPN’s Adam Schefter confirmed the Minnesota Vikings and Baltimore Ravens inquired on the QB, indicating the Colts could have gotten at least a marginal asset on top of saving the remaining money owed on his contract.

Instead, they kept him for an extra 10 days, then released him Friday to avoid triggering an injury guarantee of $10.5 million that would have been owed by the Colts if Jones got hurt.

In all, Indianapolis paid one of the most mediocre quarterbacks in the league $49.8 million for 11 games of putrid performance while now incurring more than $35 million in dead salary cap money for 2027.

Just a spectacular display of incompetence across the board.

So to recap …

The Colts, who will turn back to former first-round draft bust Anthony Richardson at QB for the time being, have no franchise QB, no first-round pick in a solid QB draft year, no wide receivers of note, a diminished offensive line after trading away Nelson, a bad defense, an ongoing search for a general manager, a lame-duck head coach, a whole bunch of dead salary cap money for 2027 and a seemingly meddling owner whose presence on the sideline during games is going to turn off at least some GM/head coach targets.

But at least they still have the third-highest-paid running back in the league in the midst of a career-worst season whose current contract will expire before the team is realistically in contention again!

Honestly, even Ossenfort couldn’t have mismanaged … literally everything that badly.

Hey, maybe he’d take the job!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.